The SEC Looks to the Most Vulnerable

Read Global Regulatory Outlook 2018 

“There’s just no room for someone who ruins someone else’s life using the capital markets to do so,” he went on.1 In fact, though, that’s not true. There’s all too much room; as Clayton noted, the continuing scale of retail fraud is surprising.

Examples are shocking:

  • An adviser who raised more than $6 million from elderly investors, promising to pay their bills, handle their taxes and invest on their behalf, but instead channelc1ed the money to himself, business expenses and friends.2
  • Boiler room cold callers pressuring senior citizens to purchase penny stocks and telling those complaining to “get a gun and blow [their] head off.”3
  • Investment scams targeting online dating sites, offering companionship and love—for a modest investment.4

Clayton is right to condemn such activity, but he was less vocal on why retail fraud remains so rampant. One key reason is, arguably, the Dodd-Frank Act.

With Dodd-Frank, Congress got things completely backward. It directed the SEC to unregister essentially all small retail investment advisers—those managing $150 million or less—to concentrate on larger firms. The logic of doing so, in the aftermath of the financial crisis, was to focus on systemic risks to the financial system. The government wanted greater oversight of large institutional investors and, specifically, private fund managers.

In fact, it’s hard to think of anything done under the Act that has done less to contain or manage systemic risk; rather, activity has focused almost exclusively on increasing institutional investor protection—cracking down on improper allocation of expenses, for example—and other breaches of fiduciary duty.

No one would argue that institutional investors should not be protected from fraud. But, with Dodd-Frank, it was done at the expense of small investors—“Mr. & Mrs. 401(k),” as Clayton calls them. Removing the small advisers who manage their money from federal oversight left them to state regulators, where oversight and enforcement processes are inconsistent at best and nonexistent at worst. That leaves retail investors dangerously exposed, while conversely, institutional investors can now depend upon the government—in addition to their own sophisticated due diligence teams—to detect fraud, mismanagement and waste.

President Trump was elected promising to dismantle Dodd-Frank. We’re not likely to see much material revision to it soon. If the SEC can address its historic mistake regarding retail investor protection, though, it will be an achievement worth noting.

 

Sources:
1 http://videos.uschamber.com/detail/videos/latest-videos/video/5522333805001/a-discussion-with-sec-chairman-jay-clayton?autoStart=true 
2 https://www.sec.gov/litigation/litreleases/2017/lr23995.htm 
3 https://uk.reuters.com/article/usa-crime-boilerroom/u-s-charges-14-over-147-mln-new-york-boiler-room-scam-idUKL1N1K327G 
4 https://www.sec.gov/news/pressrelease/2016-116.html

The SEC Looks to the Most Vulnerable 2018-04-27T00:00:00.0000000 /insights/publications/compliance-and-regulatory-consulting/global-regulatory-outlook-2018/the-sec-looks-to-the-most-vulnerable /-/media/assets/images/publications/thumbnails/global-regulatory-outlook/gro-the-sec-looks-to-the-most-vulnerable.ashx publication {DA6CC51B-740E-439A-B283-2BBFB5326BAA} {DE05ECA4-1852-4BEF-A4E1-491CB497F9CB} {EBC1AB28-1393-493C-AF32-19B3B0B6E171} {1C3CB363-1B9A-40E2-AF19-5C433260F861} {E1E71CC6-CE33-46BD-A6CF-B547EF2D052C} {4FD55120-2DD8-4DB5-8DAA-3D9212C2436D} {4984481D-079C-4B42-B985-EA34752D3CD5} {E8669D15-7AE5-41D4-BE77-6C5E07C03F38} {36EE33A2-B269-45FC-8D7C-A5B66255C61E} {19B96101-31A4-4C6D-9597-A39E0C9E24C8} {910B8B61-AD72-44CF-87C2-BFA5FE119417} {742DB722-E4B5-4E18-A540-4BFA6F8D6843} {AB22E3A7-0FD2-43A7-91E0-C3590E9141B9} {5AA4BE28-97DD-427B-A8CA-7B3BF3B5E4BF} {C9A6FAA4-0FA0-40A8-B4D2-2A0DDD29F14D} {F9A927B5-B65A-4F14-B590-DD46B5DC907A} {063D2ACD-1006-4DAD-8E9F-A8084C7358F8} {2361D727-0847-4B20-B8E9-68E7DBA5C7DC} {06F92A80-3DC4-43D6-B936-0DCE2BB89559} {DAF820AB-1213-4246-A672-5E88174F7D70} {7290AF49-EA68-489A-AE17-153A25C33B81} {0CB8F4F1-E472-4C36-B0B1-F2DB233070CA} {B062D54C-1425-4A04-8F9F-95EA14068E6D} {5BF06FE7-E88C-4627-A701-3E042F076F1F} {65648E61-ED08-40DF-AEE6-DB90ABD49289} {C8894F56-FF6C-4DEA-AB91-58D66A7F0624} {B7CF2537-1DBA-485F-A14F-8BD1524F1A8B} {95D7F66C-11BB-4E7D-B07C-48874A321F98}

Related Services

Duff & Phelps Compliance and Regulatory Consulting

Compliance and Regulatory Consulting

By Jurisdiction

Regionally targeted assistance for asset managers in compliance program development, implementation and maintenance

By Jurisdiction
Duff & Phelps Compliance and Regulatory Consulting

Compliance and Regulatory Consulting

U.S. Regulation

Comprehensive support for asset managers registering in the U.S.

U.S. Regulation
Duff & Phelps Compliance and Regulatory Consulting

Compliance and Regulatory Consulting

EU Regulation

Comprehensive compliance and regulatory support for EU firms.

EU Regulation
Duff & Phelps Compliance and Regulatory Consulting

Compliance and Regulatory Consulting

UK Regulation

Comprehensive compliance and regulatory support for FCA authorized firms.

UK Regulation
Duff & Phelps Compliance and Regulatory Consulting

Compliance and Regulatory Consulting

Irish Regulation

Comprehensive support for asset managers registering in Ireland.

Irish Regulation
Duff & Phelps Compliance and Regulatory Consulting

Compliance and Regulatory Consulting

Hong Kong Regulation

Comprehensive SFC licensing support.

Hong Kong Regulation
Duff & Phelps Compliance and Regulatory Consulting

Compliance and Regulatory Consulting

Singapore Regulation

Comprehensive MAS licensing support.

Singapore Regulation
Duff & Phelps Compliance and Regulatory Consulting

Compliance and Regulatory Consulting

Channel Islands Services

Range of regulatory and compliance consulting services for firms registered in the Channel Islands.

Channel Islands Services
Duff & Phelps Compliance and Regulatory Consulting

Compliance and Regulatory Consulting

Global Advice and Consulting

Assistance to develop, implement, and manage global compliance and regulatory consulting programs.

Global Advice and Consulting
Duff & Phelps Compliance and Regulatory Consulting

Compliance and Regulatory Consulting

Compliance Due Diligence

Regulatory operational due diligence for asset managers.

Compliance Due Diligence
Duff & Phelps Compliance and Regulatory Consulting

Compliance and Regulatory Consulting

Cybersecurity Services

Cybersecurity support for asset managers.

Cybersecurity Services
Duff & Phelps Compliance and Regulatory Consulting

Compliance and Regulatory Consulting

Financial Crime Prevention

Guidance on preventing financial crime.

Financial Crime Prevention
Duff & Phelps Compliance and Regulatory Consulting

Compliance and Regulatory Consulting

Hosted Regulatory Solution

FCA hosted regulatory solution for UK and EU asset managers.

Hosted Regulatory Solution
Duff & Phelps Compliance and Regulatory Consulting

Compliance and Regulatory Consulting

Market Services

Assistance with markets, transaction reporting and surveillance.

Market Services
Duff & Phelps Compliance and Regulatory Consulting

Compliance and Regulatory Consulting

Regulatory Enforcement

Compliance support during an enforcement investigation.

Regulatory Enforcement
Duff & Phelps Compliance and Regulatory Consulting

Compliance and Regulatory Consulting

Regulatory Tax Advisory

Global tax services uniquely customized for asset managers.

Regulatory Tax Advisory
Duff & Phelps Compliance and Regulatory Consulting

Compliance and Regulatory Consulting

Risk Consulting

Assistance to investment managers who want to better understand, monitor and disclose their risk.

Risk Consulting
Duff & Phelps Compliance and Regulatory Consulting

Compliance and Regulatory Consulting

Management Company Services

Infrastructure, staff and supervision for AIFM/UCITS ManCo duties.

Management Company Services
Duff & Phelps Valuation Advisory Services

Valuation Advisory

Valuation and consulting for financial reporting, federal, state and local tax, investment and risk management purposes.

Valuation Advisory
Duff & Phelps Valuation Advisory Services

Valuation Advisory

Alternative Asset Advisory

Transparent valuations of illiquid investments and complex securities and liquidity solutions through secondary market transactions.

Alternative Asset Advisory
Duff & Phelps Valuation Advisory Services

Valuation Advisory

Portfolio Valuation

Alternative investment valuation for private equity and hedge funds.

Portfolio Valuation
Duff & Phelps Disputes

Governance, Risk, Investigations and Disputes

Combined Duff & Phelps and Kroll disputes, investigations, cyber, business intelligence, cross-border restructuring and other advisory.

Governance, Risk, Investigations and Disputes
Duff & Phelps Disputes

Governance, Risk, Investigations and Disputes

Securities Litigation

Assistance with complex securities litigation.

Securities Litigation